1) Text and translation base

The mishnah states that workers who are working can recite the Shema even standing on the top of a tree or a row of stones a wall under construction; this does not allow for the Amidá, which requires intention of the heart (kavanat ha-lev).

VIDEO CLASS #011 IN SPANISH

2) a conceptual topic: how much kavaná requires each prayer?

• Keriat Shema: the Halachah fixed the kavaná is essential, as a minimum, on the first verse (“Shema, Israel...”), where is “accepts the yoke of the Kingdom of Heaven.” The source talmudic classic is Berachot 13b, and thus encodes the Shulchan Aruch OJ 60:5.
• Amidá: required kavaná continuous and stable, posture and environment chords (standing, quiet, no distractions). Therefore, not allowed to pray in volatile situations or hazardous (as on a tree/scaffold). This difference in practice is exactly what distinguishes our mishnah. (Doctrinal summary from the chapters of “Kriat Shema” and “Tefillah” in compendia halájicos contemporaries.)

3) Reason of the distinction (according to the Rishonim/Aharonim)

• Bartenura (ad loc.) he explains that, in height, the worker fear of falling and your mind is divided; for Shema enough to concentrate on the first versesomething viable even there, but the Amidá requires more.
• Rambam systematizes: the worker interrupted the work to say the whole of the first section of Shema with the kavaná due, and you can continue the rest working; even if you are standing on a tree or a wall you can read the Shema there.

VIDEO CLASS #011 IN ENGLISH

4) Scope of practical epistemology

(a) Position and place to Shema

• You can recite in any position (standing, sitting, walking) and, in our case, even in high places while workingalways saving the kavaná minimum of the first verse and without putting at risk the life.

(b) Interruption of work

• The Talmud and the codes off that the worker must pause at least during the first verse (and, according to Rambam, the first section) to ensure kavaná; then you can continue to reciting while you work.

c) Amidá

• Must descend and pray in a safe place, with stillness postural and concentration sustained; do this on the top of a tree or a row of stones it is not valid by missing the kavaná required. The general line of the poskim is unequivocal to prohibit pray Amidá in conditions that break the mental stability/posture.

5) Kavaná in Shema: fine detail

• Core compulsory: first verse with the full intended meaning (divine oneness and acceptance of the yoke of heaven). If you missed kavaná there, it is not meet the mitzvah. (Berachot 13b; SA OJ 60:5; developments in modern teaching).
• Rest of the Shema: while it is preferable to focus on all, ex post facto the compliance pivots about the first verse (with the subtle nuances between Rishonim).

6) Dimension labour and “theft of time”

The mishnah, the allow the workers recite in situ, balances two values:

1. Fulfilment of the Shema your time,
2. Not harm the employer to delay unduly the task.
   That's why requires pausing the minimum necessary to ensure kavaná and, then, continue. (Summary from the traditional exposition of 2:4.)

7) post-Encoding

• Shulchan Aruch OJ 60:5: enshrines the rule of kavaná indispensable in the first verse.
• Tradition coded summaries halájicos): repeat the same practice guidelines (pause for kavaná of the first verse, flexibility, place of rest, difference blunt with Amidá).

8) doctrinal Synthesis

• Shema requires kavaná focused (minimum, first verse). That's why the mishnah allows you to recite it even in physical contexts precarious where the mind is not fully subdued, always ensure that kavaná minimum.
• Amidá requires kavaná profound and sustained + position/environment formal; in consequence not permitted reciting it in places or situations that undermine that concentration (such as a tree or a row of stones).
• Guiding principle: the measure of concentration required by the nature of the avodah defines the requirement space/postural.